Special Instructions: First puzzle, feedback welcome.

Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

12 comments

Really nice! 1a I particularly enjoyed. I did have one thought, which I'll add in a reply to hide spoilers. I've only just published my first crossword so take my feedback with a pinch of salt.

E
A
Last reply 2 days agoView thread

Thanks EssBee and congrats on your first puzzle. My fave was 3d for the smooth believable surface, also liked 5a, 6a & 4d. If you're in the market for hopefully constructive feedback, spoilers follow ...

E
F
Last reply 2 days agoView thread

The clue style reminded me of Cyclops a bit. A fun solve - 2d was probably my favourite. I agree with rest of the feedback here, so I'd just add one tiny note...

E
S
Last reply 2 days agoView thread
Setter

Thanks everybody for the input, and the opportunity to discuss clue writing. Much appreciated.